In this episode of Wonderfully Witchy, we’re talking about one of witchcraft’s funniest contradictions. We know that magic comes from intention, energy and will, not expensive tools or beautiful accessories. So why, oh why, do we still want every shiny crystal, tarot deck and witchy little trinket we lay our eyes on?

As a self-confessed overconsumer with far too many tarot decks, a weakness for pretty things and crystals that have literally become bookends, I’m very much part of the problem. We’ll talk about our magpie brains, the thrill of buying new magical tools, the purchases that surprise us, and the ones that end up gathering dust despite our best intentions.

I’m also sharing how I’m trying to retrain my own shopping habits, from limiting what I buy to rediscovering the treasures I already own. This isn’t about giving up beautiful things or feeling guilty for wanting them. It’s about recognising the difference between wanting, enjoying and needing something, while remembering that our magic was never dependent on how much we own.

Listen Now

Key Takeaways

Our magic doesn’t depend on our tools
We know that intention, energy and will are at the heart of witchcraft, yet we still find ourselves wanting more crystals, candles and tarot decks. That’s the paradox, and even experienced witches aren’t immune to it.

The magpie brain is very good at justifying purchases
When something catches our eye, we can find all sorts of magical reasons why we need it. Sometimes a new tool genuinely enriches our practice, and sometimes it’s simply a beautiful thing we want to own.

Intention doesn’t always predict which tools we’ll connect with
A carefully considered tarot deck might never feel right, while an impulsively purchased oracle deck can become a favourite. Our relationships with magical tools aren’t always as predictable as we’d like to believe.

Small shopping boundaries can make a big difference
Limiting colours, materials or types of tools, waiting before making purchases and spending more time with what we already own can help us become more intentional shoppers without giving up the things we love.

Wanting, enjoying and needing are three different things
You can love a crystal without needing to buy it, and you can purchase a tarot deck simply because you adore the artwork. The important thing is recognising why you want something and remembering that owning more doesn’t make you a more powerful witch.

Transcript

Podcast Name: Wonderfully Witchy Podcast with Bry Jaimea
Episode No: 07, 14 November 2026
Topic: The Witchy Shopping Paradox

Welcome to the Wonderfully Witchy Podcast. I’m Bry Jaimea, and today I’m talking about something I’m deeply qualified to discuss, because I am very much part of the problem. We’re talking about the witchcraft shopping paradox.

As witches, we say over and over again that our power comes from within. That witchcraft is about intention, energy, will and belief, and that we don’t need expensive tools or elaborate rituals to make magic happen. A candle from the supermarket works just as well as a beautifully handcrafted one, and sometimes we don’t even need the candle.

And yet we still want all the shiny things. The crystals, the candles, the tarot decks, the altar accessories, the little bottles and jars, and anything else that looks remotely magical. We know we don’t need them, and that apparently has no effect on the wanting.

So in one corner, we have intention. Calm, grounded, endlessly reliable. And in the other corner, we have the magpie brain, holding a credit card and saying, but have you seen this one? That, my lovely witches, is the paradox.

I’ll be the first to admit that I’m an overconsumer. I own a frankly ridiculous number of tarot decks, and I’m not going to tell you how many, because some of you have heard about my living room floor and I’d like to maintain at least a little dignity.

I also have a rather extensive crystal collection. Some of those crystals have been used in spellwork, some were chosen for particular intentions, and others have ended up as bookends. Yes, actual bookends. Which is a fairly good sign that I have more crystals than I genuinely need.

And yet, show me a beautiful piece of rose quartz or an interesting bit of obsidian, and you can practically hear the magpie in my brain waking up.

Oh, that’s lovely. I should have that.
For what, Bry?
Well, I’m sure I’ll think of something.

What makes it so funny is that I’ve been practising witchcraft for more than thirty years. I know perfectly well that I can cast a spell with a candle, a pinch of something from the pantry and a few carefully chosen words. Some of my most meaningful workings have involved nothing beyond my own energy and intention. Intention has never once let me down.

But knowing that doesn’t make me any less delighted by the prospect of another beautiful witchy thing.

So why do we do it?

Part of it is simply that witchcraft is a wonderfully sensory practice. We work with colour, scent, texture, symbolism and beautiful objects. We choose crystals for their associations, candles for their colours, and tarot decks because the imagery speaks to something within us. When a practice invites you to work with so many materials, it’s hardly surprising that you develop a fondness for collecting them.

But there’s a difference between enjoying tools and convincing ourselves we need them, and the magpie brain is a master of that one. It is the most gifted lawyer I have ever met. A new candle holder? Well, I use candles. Another crystal? Different stones have different associations. A new tarot deck? Perhaps it’ll offer a fresh perspective.

You see where I’m going with this. We can be wonderfully creative when it comes to explaining why another purchase is a sensible investment in our magical practice. And sometimes it genuinely is. A new tool can open up a different way of working, or become something we treasure for years.

But sometimes it’s just another pretty thing that ends up on the shelf. Or holding up a book.

Take tarot. I absolutely love it. I’ve been reading for decades, and I have decks I know intimately, their symbolism, their personalities, the way each one speaks to me. Do I need another deck to become a better reader? Absolutely not. Am I going to fall hopelessly in love with the next beautifully illustrated deck I come across? Almost certainly.

And it isn’t only tarot. New oracle decks are coming out all the time, which feels slightly unfair to those of us with a magpie brain. I recently bought the Inner Temple Oracle after about zero seconds of thought. No deliberating, no sleeping on it, no little chat with my intentions. I just wanted it. And it turned out to be incredibly powerful. I talk about it in my November newsletter, so if you’re subscribed, you’ll know that the magpie does occasionally come home with something genuinely wonderful.

Then there’s the other side of the ledger. I have tarot decks I bought with great intention that I simply cannot read. The Witches Wisdom Tarot was the first deck I bought after I moved back to Australia from Scotland. Oh, Scotland, I miss you so much and I can’t wait to move home. But I digress. I fully expected us to be lifelong friends. We are not. Meanwhile, the deck I grabbed on a whim has been a revelation. It seems my shopping instincts and my good intentions are not always on speaking terms.

And there’s something rather lovely about the anticipation, too. The little rush when you find it, the excitement of ordering it, the pleasure of waiting for the parcel to arrive. I’ll look at a deck and imagine how I’ll work with it, which spread I’ll try first and where it will live alongside the others. By the time I’ve finished, I’ve practically convinced myself that the deck and I have a spiritual appointment.

Then it arrives, and sometimes I fall completely in love with it. Other times I admire it, put it away, and find myself looking at another deck a few weeks later. The magpie got her shiny thing, and she’s already scanning the horizon for the next one.

I have tried to put some limits on her, and they’ve been genuinely helpful. For spellwork, I only use black and white candles. My crystals are generally black, white or pink, and when I need herbs, I head straight to the pantry. I don’t buy elaborate spell kits or dozens of different coloured candles, because I’ve learnt I can do everything I need with a much simpler collection.

I’ve actually extended similar rules to most of my shopping. I only wear a certain style of heel, so I don’t end up buying shoes I’ll never wear. I only buy clothing in certain colours, which stops a lot of impulse purchases before they start. It turns out the magpie is much easier to manage when she has a smaller sky to fly around in.

These little rules stop me getting distracted by every possible option, and they push me to work creatively with what I already have. Of course, there’s still an extraordinary number of black, white and pink crystals in the world, so it’s hardly a foolproof system. And don’t even get me started on tarot decks, because apparently I’ve decided those are exempt from every rule I’ve ever made.

What I’ve started doing instead is checking in with myself before I buy. Is it because I have a particular working in mind? Because I genuinely love the object? Or because I’ve got that familiar itch for something new? Sometimes the answer is simply that I want a treat, and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that. I love beautiful things and I’m not about to pretend otherwise. What I’m trying to change is the automatic assumption that wanting something means I should buy it.

So when something catches my eye now, I give it a little time. Sometimes I still want it a week later, and sometimes I’ve completely forgotten it existed, which is rather revealing when I was convinced I couldn’t live without it three days earlier. I’m also making more of an effort to use what I’ve already collected. To spend time with my decks, rediscover the crystals tucked away in drawers, and enjoy the lovely little objects I’ve spent years bringing into my home. What’s the point of having all these beautiful things if I’m so busy looking for the next one that I forget to appreciate what’s already here?

I think that’s the lesson in all of this. It isn’t that buying witchy things is bad, or that we should all become minimalists with one candle and a bowl of salt. Goodness knows that isn’t happening in my house. If you’ve seen my Instagram, you’ll know I’m a maximalist at heart, and I also have an extensive shoe collection, because this witch has a thing for four inch heels. It’s recognising that wanting something, enjoying something and needing something are three very different things.

I can love a crystal without needing to own it. I can appreciate a beautiful deck without convincing myself it’s going to transform my readings. And I can buy something purely because it makes me happy, without dressing the purchase up as a spiritual necessity.

Because the witchcraft shopping paradox isn’t something we need to solve completely. It’s a funny little contradiction that comes from loving a practice that tells us our power is internal while surrounding ourselves with beautiful things that represent it. The trick, at least for me, is remembering which one comes first.

You are not less of a witch if you own three candles. You are not more of a witch if you own three hundred. Your magic doesn’t live in your collection. It lives in your attention, your intention and the way you show up. And I think remembering that makes it a little easier to enjoy the shiny things without convincing ourselves that we need every single one of them.

So the next time I’m standing in front of a beautiful display of crystals, trying to work out which one absolutely must come home with me, I’ll remind myself that a bit of sparkle is allowed. Especially when I’ve already got a perfectly good piece of rose quartz holding up my books.

Thank you for joining me for this episode of the Wonderfully Witchy Podcast. You can find more reflections, stories and spells over at wonderfullywitchyweb.com, where you can also sign up for my monthly newsletter, or come and say hi on Instagram at bryjaimea. I’d love to hear about your own witchy shopping habits, especially if you’re a fellow magpie with a collection that’s getting slightly out of hand.

And if today’s episode made you feel a little seen, please share it with someone who might need to hear it.

I’ll see you next time. And until then, be intentional, enjoy the shiny things, and keep trusting your magic.

With love,Bry Jaimea

Wonderfully Witchy Podcast!

Apple PodcastsSpotifyPodbeanAmazon MusiciHeartRadioPlayer.fmListen NotesPodchaser

Look What We’re Reading!


Discover more from Wonderfully Witchy Web

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

You may also like...