In this episode of Wonderfully Witchy, we’re talking about one of the stranger forms of witchy gatekeeping: the belief that someone can somehow be more of a witch than someone else. And yes, this episode was inspired by a very confident Pisces man who slid into my Instagram DMs and informed me, completely unprompted, that he was more of a witch than me.

From there, we’re unpacking the difference between experience and superiority, why expertise deserves respect without becoming a ranking system, and how easily knowledge can turn into status when people start competing over who’s the most magical person in the room.

This episode is for anyone who’s ever been corrected for sport, dismissed because their path looked different, or made to feel like their practice wasn’t serious enough. There is no witchcraft scoreboard, no percentage rating, and no one standing at the door deciding whether you qualify.

Listen Now

Key Takeaways

Experience and superiority are not the same thing
Someone can have decades of practice, deep training or specialist knowledge without being more of a witch than someone else. Experience deserves respect, but it doesn’t create a hierarchy of worth.

Different paths have different measures
Initiatory traditions, solitary practice, astrology, hedge witchcraft, kitchen witchcraft and countless other paths all have their own structures and strengths. What matters within one tradition isn’t automatically a ruler for everyone else.

Knowledge shouldn’t become a weapon
Sharing what you know can build community. Using knowledge to shame, correct for sport or establish status does the opposite. Good teachers can explain what they know without needing everyone else to feel small.

Your practice isn’t available for public scoring
Intuition, connection, ritual and personal meaning aren’t things another person can accurately measure from the outside. Nobody gets to stand over your practice with a clipboard and assign you a witchcraft score.

Community matters more than competition
The question isn’t who is more magical. It’s whether we can remain curious, generous and open enough to learn from one another without turning witchcraft into a contest nobody needed in the first place.

Transcript

Podcast Name: Wonderfully Witchy Podcast with Bry Jaimea
Episode No: 08, 21 November 2026
Topic: I’m More of a Witch Than You

Welcome to the Wonderfully Witchy Podcast. I’m Bry Jaimea, and ooh, look at that, a little clickbait title today. I’m More of a Witch Than You. I promise there’s a story behind it, and it’s a good one.

So, recently, a man slid into my DMs on Instagram, wanting to get to know me better. Lovely. Flattering. I needed a distraction from the disappointment of Incredibly Attractive Nomadic Giant. So yes, Let’s see where this goes.

The first conversation was an argument about how each zodiac sign dresses. And when I say argument, I mean he asked my opinion, I gave it, and then he told me I was wrong. About astrology. Which I’ve studied for years. Fine. Moving on.

Our next interaction was him asking to meet, saying he liked my astrology knowledge and my cute looks. And I admitted, honestly, that this was refreshing, because most men find the witchy thing off putting.

To which he responded, and I quote, “I am more of a witch than you.”

Now, I’m no expert in the art of wooing, but I’m fairly sure that isn’t the best way to win a woman to your cause.

He carried on rambling about astrology, and then informed me that he was only still talking to me because I was a Taurus. Oh, sir. I am so flattered. Truly.

So of course I asked him which signs he doesn’t like. He told me he was very strict about the women he talks to, and that Sagittarius, Libra, Gemini and Leo were completely off the cards.

Well, sir, how unfortunate. Because I have a Sagittarius stellium, a Libra stellium, my Venus is in Gemini, and my Part of Fortune is in Leo. What a shame. We’re simply not compatible. And he was promptly blocked.

Now, I’m telling you this story for fun, and I hope you’re laughing. But the caboose on my train of thought is much bigger than one very confident Pisces man in my inbox. It’s the whole idea that one person can be more of a witch than another. And the people who think they’re witchier than thou.

So let’s get into it.

First, let’s just look at that sentence on its own. I am more of a witch than you. What would that even mean? More of a witch in what way? More years of practice? More knowledge? More tools? More followers? More intensity? There’s no scoreboard. There’s no official ranking. Nobody hands out a certificate at the door and says, congratulations, you’re now seventy three percent witch.

Witchcraft isn’t a pyramid. I said that in my episode about the term baby witch, and I’ll say it again here, because this is the same conversation wearing a different hat. The baby witch label puts new witches below us. The more witch than you attitude puts everybody else below one person. It’s the same hierarchy, just with a louder voice.

And when I hear someone say something like that, I rarely read it as confidence. Genuine confidence doesn’t usually need to announce itself or win the room. A person who’s secure in their practice isn’t threatened by yours, and doesn’t need to tell you that they’re better.

Now, let me be fair, because there’s a nuance here. There are real differences between practitioners. Some people have been practising for decades. Some are initiated into particular traditions, with training, lineage and structure that matter deeply to them. Some have spent years studying herbs, astrology, divination or ritual in great detail. That depth is real, and it deserves respect.

But depth is not the same as worth. Having more experience in one area doesn’t make someone more of a witch. It makes them more experienced in that area. Someone who’s studied astrology for twenty years may know very little about hedge witchcraft. Someone with an intuitive, kitchen based practice may have a wisdom that no book can teach. Different paths, different strengths. None of them cancels the others out.

It’s also worth saying that being in a structured tradition and being a solitary eclectic practitioner aren’t a ladder. They’re simply different ways of walking. A person in an initiatory tradition has their own measures of progress within it, and that’s theirs to honour. But those measures belong to that path. They were never meant to be a ruler held against everyone else.

And a quick word on the man in my DMs. This isn’t about one gender, one personality or one corner of the internet. Anyone can fall into the habit of needing to be the most magical person in the room. I just happened to meet a particularly entertaining example in my inbox.

And there’s another point, which is that a lot of the things people use to measure witchiness are things that can’t really be measured. How strong is your intuition? How deep is your connection? How meaningful are your rituals? These are personal, private and shifting. Nobody else gets to stand outside your practice with a clipboard and assign you a witchcraft score.

Let’s also talk about the things people use as credentials, because they’re slippery. The number of years you’ve been practising. The tradition you follow. The tools you own. The size of your following. The books you’ve read. None of those, on their own, make someone a good witch, or even a better one.

So how do you spot the witchier than thou energy? Here are a few signs I’ve noticed.

Correcting for sport. There’s a difference between sharing helpful information and needing to prove someone wrong. If a conversation turns into a contest, it’s not about learning anymore.

Dismissing other paths. If someone tells you that your way of practising isn’t real, or isn’t proper, or isn’t enough, take a breath. Ask yourself what they’re protecting.

Using knowledge as a weapon. Real teachers share. They guide, they invite questions, they say, I don’t know, when they don’t. People who use knowledge as status tend to hoard it, shame others with it, or perform it.

Needing to be the authority. If a person can’t admit uncertainty, it’s worth wondering how much of what they know is actually lived.

Making it about superiority instead of service. Magic is something you do, in the world, for yourself and for others. If it’s primarily a way of feeling better than other people, it’s lost the plot.

And, I’ll add, using astrology as a rulebook for dismissing whole groups of people. Look, I love astrology. But reducing someone to their Sun sign, or ruling out a quarter of the zodiac without ever meeting them, isn’t a deep reading. It’s a shortcut. A full chart is a rich, layered thing. It’s not a single label, and it certainly doesn’t tell you whether someone is worth a conversation. If it did, I assure you my stelliums would have a few things to say.

Now, I want to turn this around for a moment, because I think we’ve all got a little bit of this in us. We might not say it out loud, but have you ever caught yourself thinking, I’ve been doing this longer than her? Or, they’re not serious about it, they’ve only just started? Or, that’s not how you’re meant to do it? I have. I think it’s human. We like to feel that our effort counts.

But the question is what we do with that thought. We can let it harden into superiority, or we can let it soften into curiosity. What does this person know that I don’t? What can I learn from the way they practise? What can I offer if they ask?

That’s the difference between community and competition.

The truth is, the world doesn’t need witchier than thou. It needs more witches who are open, honest and kind. Witches who say, I’m still learning, and mean it. Witches who say, that’s not my path, but I’m glad it’s yours. Witches who show up for each other and trust that there’s room for everyone.

So if anyone ever tells you they’re more of a witch than you, here’s my suggestion. Smile politely. Check their moon sign if you’re feeling cheeky. And then quietly go back to your own practice, because it was never theirs to rank.

Thank you for joining me for this episode of the Wonderfully Witchy Podcast. You can find more reflections, stories and spells over at wonderfullywitchyweb.com, where you can also sign up for my monthly newsletter, or come and say hi on Instagram at bryjaimea. I’d love to hear the most ridiculous witchier than thou comment you’ve ever received.

And if today’s episode made you laugh about the state of the dating world these days, please share it with someone who might need to hear it.

I’ll see you next time. And until then, stay humble, stay curious, and keep trusting your magic.

With love, Bry Jaimea

Wonderfully Witchy Podcast!

Apple PodcastsSpotifyPodbeanAmazon MusiciHeartRadioPlayer.fmListen NotesPodchaser

Look What We’re Reading!


Discover more from Wonderfully Witchy Web

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

You may also like...